By the way, we bought a house
I also noted that we preferred the look and feel of older homes; divided light windows; hardwood floors instead of carpet; the sort of quirks and weird spaces that you get in old houses that not new...but we also wanted a master bathroom, we would like a mudroom or at least a nice entryway with good closets, and I prefer forced-air heat to radiators (in part because I really love having central air for those weeks in the summer when you really want it).
We wound up buying a house built in 1950. The windows aren't divided light, although I think we could buy fake dividers from Andersen (we haven't yet). (Oh, and people always say, "oooooh, Andersen, those are great!!!" The windows were installed in the late 1990s and two of them are now seriously non-functional; I need to call a repair guy to have him come service them. And FTR they are not under warranty -- the warranty is way more limited than they claim in their marketing, at least for this model of window. They are nice windows but they are not, in fact, all that and a bag of chips.
What was funny, looking at my particular pet peeves, was that we avoided all of them very nicely.
1. The kitchen is big but extremely well-designed. It's probably got the best layout of any house we looked at and was a big part of what sold us on the house.
2. The interior doors are all the boring flat wood but they are WOOD, not vinyl.
3. The master bathroom is small and sort of shoehorned in. The master bedroom also has a small greenhouse (!) -- tiled floor with a drain, wire shelves, a skylight, a faucet for a hose hookup. The seller noted at closing that she was pretty sure the greenhouse had made the house harder to sell -- people looked at it and were disgruntled not to be getting an enormous bathroom instead of a small bathroom plus a greenhouse. We're not entirely sure what we'll do with a greenhouse (so far, we've been putting plants in it, but the sad truth is that we are not very good at growing stuff) but we did not look at it and think, "dangit, why isn't this extra bathroom space?"
The house was also mostly hardwood -- there was one room with carpet, and we had the carpet taken out and hardwood installed. (The kitchen is hardwood. That is one place we wouldn't install it, but we'll live with it and see how it goes.) We didn't get a mudroom but there is a WEALTH of downstairs closets, and a nice tiled area by the front door for you to drip on when you come in that way.
Anyway. We're in the process of painting. Two rooms had wallpaper (and now they don't!) and there are various other fixes and upgrades that are easier before you move your furniture in. Molly's room had a ceiling fan, which we downgraded to a light fixture because she wants a loft bed. Kiera's room had a light fixture which was pretty but unfortunately had no globe to shield the bulb, and on measuring and trying various things I'm not sure we're going to be able to find a replacement globe that will work (besides, a light fixture with two bulbs will light her room better). A bunch of the outlets were two-prong grounded, which we had swapped for three-prong grounded. Etc.
We move in November. And I should really return to packing files.